- [WT] [Home] [Manage]
Nipaa~
[Return]
Posting mode: Reply
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
File 1
Password (for post and file deletion)
Extra [ Is Spoiler ]
  • Supported file types are: jpg,jpeg,png,gif
  • Maximum file size allowed is 48.83mb.
File: 1206689817431aq3_ib4f.png - (17.93kb, 400x500, 1206689817431aq3.png) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.
BIRDGET BIRDGET 07/11/2009(Sat)06:20:48 No.356823  
I still have not touched Umineko and I don't know why. Can someone explain to me why it is so good and why I should pick it up. I'd like to do something with it before it passes me over and I forget about it.
Expand All Images
>>
Anonymous 08/11/2009(Sun)09:11:57 No.358100
File: 6763981_ib4f.png - (47.51kb, 400x300, 6763981.png)
It's a very inventive mystery with an absolutely top-of-the-line music track. The setting starts simple but gets very deep, and the characterization is very nice.

Its flaws are bad art and appalling pacing. Takes at least 2 hours (up to 4) till the story starts up, and even then the first EP has a rather slow pace throughout. EP2 has another slow intro, about 1 hour long, before it picks up and only then does the story finally goes into full gear (with the introduction of Red and clarification of rules).

However, possibly because it takes such a long time, the atmosphere is second to none and absolutely top-class. Umineko's atmosphere is by far its biggest selling point.

The mystery deepens quite quickly, especially if you're one to believe everything you're told. The trickiest parts is to work out if there's any truth in the quarry of lies laid out for you. For inventive minds, it's a goldmine of mystery. For people who don't want to think, then you can just believe magic exists!


Plus, everyone's dressed fancy.
>>
Rozencrab!oVER9000cQ 08/11/2009(Sun)05:09:38 No.358457
File: 1247401548996_ib4f.png - (47.03kb, 167x177, 1247401548996.png)
>>358100
>mystery
Ryukishi says no. It's more like an anti-mystery, we see everything but the protagonist goes out of his way to deny it.

>Its flaws are bad art and appalling pacing
I agree that the pacing is awful, but the art grows on you.

Also Birdget smells.
>>
Anonymous 09/11/2009(Mon)12:22:41 No.359045
File: 1246900865546_ib4f.jpg - (19.18kb, 342x403, 1246900865546.jpg)
>>358457

>Ryukishi says no

Ugh, learn to read subtext. Or re-read that letter entirely, because you might be blind.
"'Is guesswork possible or impossible in Umineko no Naku Koro ni?'
The genre of this work is probably a serial murder mystery.
However, that does not guarantee that reasoning and guesswork are possible.
Those who enjoy stupid puzzles that are made to be solved can leave now.
Umineko no Naku Koro ni is the worst kind of tale, created without any intention of letting all of you solve it."

Honestly, if you take what he says at face value when he outright says "The culprit is a witch. All alibis and tricks are magic. This is not a mystery, but fantasy!", then you've already surrendered to the witch. Go lick her shoes, dirty furniture.

(Besides, the last line of that letter is "Will you surrender to the witch, or stand up and face her?", which is a direct challenge to that. Don't be silly.)
>>
Pedonymous 09/11/2009(Mon)04:18:13 No.361092
File: url_0_ib4f.jpg - (79.81kb, 640x532, url.jpg)
Its all just goofy art, IMO.

Pic related, it's Battler taking a poop.

Edited at 09/11/2009(Mon)04:18:35
>>
spire 09/11/2009(Mon)10:03:50 No.361614
File: creepy-maria_ib4f.jpg - (25.48kb, 677x384, creepy-maria.jpg)
What's NOT to like.
It has delicacies
:)
>>
D. Goldengate 11/11/2009(Wed)12:01:20 No.364301
File: a1871030a7db4606a2adcb6f70e7a500_ib4f.png - (649.04kb, 584x838, a1871030a7db4606a2adcb6f70e7a500.png)
>>361614
Maria's decapitated head kind of reminds me of tako luka.
>>
Caleb!gfG/jZIKRk 11/11/2009(Wed)12:26:51 No.364333
File: 1253133564167_ib4f.jpg - (43.02kb, 640x320, 1253133564167.jpg)
>>364301

I don't think you're the only one.
>>
Caleb!gfG/jZIKRk 11/11/2009(Wed)12:26:52 No.364334
File: 1253133678982_ib4f.jpg - (102.44kb, 512x512, 1253133678982.jpg)
>>364333
>>
Caleb!gfG/jZIKRk 11/11/2009(Wed)12:26:53 No.364335
File: 1253133714420_ib4f.png - (604.91kb, 600x600, 1253133714420.png)
>>364333
>>
Caleb!gfG/jZIKRk 11/11/2009(Wed)12:26:54 No.364336
File: 1253133818936_ib4f.png - (60.54kb, 526x495, 1253133818936.png)
>>364333
>>
Anonymous 11/11/2009(Wed)12:29:21 No.364342

[ File Only] Password




The Chan Top List